What Did Jesus Eat?

Linda Dindzans, dear friend and fellow author, shares two recipes that Jesus might have enjoyed. Also, she is celebrating her debut release of A Certain Man, a Biblical fiction novel I loved! Welcome to Historical Nibbles, Linda!

by Linda Dindzans

Writers of historical fiction who want to create a story that rings true must research many aspects of everyday life. One of the most fun topics for me to research is the foods that were consumed, how they were prepared, and who would have had access to them at the time of Jesus.

The basic diet throughout Roman Palestine included a daily portion of wheat or barley bread, a portion of lentils, peas, some olive oil, and a portion of dried figs or other produce. Fish was part of the diet for those near rivers or the sea but had to be salted for situations where transport was required. Only the wealthy would have been able to readily afford meat— goat, beef, lamb. Commoners would have served meat only at feasts, weddings, or other occasions of great significance.

Kitchens did not exist. In small houses, food was cooked out back over an open fire or in a fire pit. In larger houses, a cookfire would be maintained in a central courtyard and kitchen foodstuffs were kept in a storeroom. Only the wealthiest homes had a dedicated place to cook inside and a fiery oven.

Lentils were a nutrient-rich legume that had been cultivated for thousands of years and were consumed by Romans, Jews, and Samaritans. Lentils were considered almost as important as grain and are mentioned several places in the Bible. Jacob made Esau a red lentil stew for which he traded his birthright. They are listed among the foods brought to David and his followers when they were running from King Saul.  

My debut novel, A Certain Man, set in ancient Samaria at the time of Jesus, mentions characters growing lentils, packing dried lentils to travel, or preparing lentil stew or soup, called “miqpah”, over a cookfire. The stew was often flavored with garlic and combined with other vegetables such as cabbage. What did lentil soup or stew taste like? Our modern diets are varied, so many of you may have an idea, but below is a tasty version you may enjoy.

The following recipe and photos are taken with permission from an excellent website https://thebiblecookbook.com. This site was created by Walterina Bindhu Jachin, a friend, who has combined Bible study  and her love of cooking to place the many food items or meals mentioned in the Bible  in both a spiritual and physical context. She has developed her take on those recipes to cater to today’s palate. 

Jacob’s Red Lentil soup with Oats bread

Red Lentil Soup Recipe:

1 cup red lentils (You can substitute this with yellow or green lentils)

1 cup red beans, cooked

  1. large red or white onion, chopped
  2. Tbsp. tomato paste

5 cloves garlic, minced

1 tsp. paprika

1/2 tsp. whole cumin seeds

1/2 tsp. whole peppercorns

1 cup chicken stock (Optional: if you want a vegetarian version, you can use a veggie stock )

1 tsp. Serrano peppers or any green pepper of your choice

1 cup cilantro, chopped 2 Tbsp. ghee (clarified butter) salt – as desired 

sour cream, for garnish

Method:

  1. Wash and soak the lentils for 1 hr. before starting to cook.
  2. Add the soaked lentils, salt, cumin, pepper, 1/2 of chopped onions and garlic, cilantro with 3 cups of water and pressure cook it for 3 whistles. If using a pot, let it simmer with the lid closed until the lentils are soft and mushy.
  3. In a pan, add the ghee, and heat to medium. Once the pan is hot, add a pinch of whole cumin seeds, Serrano or green peppers, the remaining chopped onions, garlic and let it cook till the onions are transparent.
  4. Add the tomato paste with a couple of teaspoons of water and once its heated through, add the chicken stock and red beans. Let this come to a boil and then add paprika and salt to taste.
  5. At this stage, add the cooked mashed lentils and let the soup simmer on low for 20 minutes.
  6. Sprinkle with the remaining cilantro, a dollop of sour cream and serve it hot with the Oat bread.

Optionally, you can serve this on rice or a side of pita bread. It’s not just delicious, but also simple and hearty. And NO… no matter how good it tastes, you cannot ask people to give up their rights in return for your soup. LOL!

Oats bread recipe:

Ingredients:

  1. cup oats flour  
  2. cups whole wheat flour

1 packet Instant yeast  

  1. Tbsp. maple syrup or honey

1/4 Tsp salt

3/4 cup warm water  

  • Tbsp. butter  

Method:

1.Combine Maple syrup, yeast, with water and let it rise till you see it foaming

2. Add the flour, salt with the yeast mixture and combine it well to form a ball shaped dough 3. Cover it and let it rest in a warm place. I have kept my dough inside the oven with the oven switched off and the lights on.

  • After 30 minutes, punch the raised dough, knead it for 2 minutes and form into your desired shape and place it in the loaf pan. And let it rise again in the pan for 30 more minutes.

Melt the butter and apply half of the butter on the dough and coat all around it. Sprinkle some oats on top.

  • Preheat the oven to 350 and bake it for 35 minutes or until a knife comes out clean when you poke in the middle. Apply the remaining butter.
  • Let it rest for 15 minutes and slice it.

Linda again…For other delicious Bible-based recipes visit https://thebiblecookbook.com. I particularly like the fig pudding with raisin jam!

Blurb

Mara, motherless since birth, is a young Samaritan beginning to discover her love for Samuel—and his for her. Having suffered thirteen years in her drunken father’s house, more servant than daughter, soon she will be deemed mature enough to marry. Will her greedy father consider her heart when he brokers a match?

Amazon

Linda Dindzans, M.D. is a writer with the heart of a healer who offers readers stories of redemption and restoration. Though her compelling characters inhabit the treacherous times of the Bible, Linda believes there is nothing new under the sun. The struggles of her characters still speak to hearts today. Connect with Linda on Facebook: Linda Dindzans, Author, and X:@lindadindzans.

The Humble American Muffin

by Pegg Thomas

Welcome back to gifted author, Pegg Thomas! Pegg was the editor for three of my early books. Her latest release, Henri’s Regret, published on July 1st! To celebrate, she has an offer for a free book. Read on to discover the details. She’s sharing a recipe for delicious Orange Muffins with us. Thanks for joining us today, Pegg!

Prior to the invention of chemical leaveners—particularly baking powder—all breads were leavened by yeast. But once baking powder became popular in the mid-1800s, quick breads soared in popularity across America. Women didn’t have to plan the day before to have a yeast batter or dough ready for baking. Anyone could whip up a muffin batter or biscuit dough and have them out of the oven to serve within the hour. What a luxury!

I enjoy making muffins for breakfast, and these orange muffins are my favorite.

Orange Muffins

11oz can Mandarin oranges

1 egg

½ cup sugar

Milk

¼ cup oil

½ cup whole wheat flour

1 ½ cups all-purpose flour

1 Tbsp baking powder

½ teas salt

Preheat oven to 400 degrees. Grease a 12-slot muffin tin or use paper inserts. Drain liquid from oranges into a measuring cup. Add enough milk to measure 1 cup. (The milk will curdle.) Mix drained oranges with egg and sugar in a mixing bowl until orange segments break apart. Stir in liquid and oil. Add dry ingredients and stir just until blended. Distribute evenly into the 12 muffin slots. Bake for 15 – 18 minutes, until muffins are done. Remove immediately from the tin and cool on a wire rack.

Fun fact: the term English Muffin was coined in the U.S. by Samuel Bath Thomas in 1880.

To celebrate her newest release Pegg is offering a free eBook of Henri’s Regret, the prequel to her Forts of Refuge Series when you subscribe to her newsletter. https://dashboard.mailerlite.com/forms/756469/109549774328301212/share

Henri’s Regret

Frenchman Henri Geroux can’t sign the oath of loyalty to the British after the end of the French and Indian War. He leaves his home behind and sets out on an adventure with his Ottawa friend, Dances Away. But heading west to trap beaver doesn’t mean he outruns his problems. Faced with a dangerous journey into an unknown land, he and Dances Away get caught up in more than they’d bargained for.

BIO:

Pegg Thomas lives in Michigan’s beautiful Upper Peninsula with Michael, her husband of *mumble* years. Besides writing, she enjoys a variety of crafts including spinning sheep’s wool into yarn and knitting her signature wool shawls. Together, she and Michael enjoy camping, fishing, gardening, boat-nerding (you have to be a Great Lakes person to know about that), and thoroughbred horse racing.

A life-long history geek, it’s no surprise that historical fiction is her genre. Colonial America and the Civil War era are favorite time periods to both read and write. She often takes inspiration from her own family tree, with 3 of her grandparents having lineage going back in America to the mid-1600s. Her favorite type of book centers on a great fiction story surrounded by factual historical events.

Pepperoni Rolls – West Virginia’s Unofficial State Food

Today’s post is written by fellow author and friend, Jennifer Allen. I love her mysteries and am looking forward to reading her newest release. Welcome back to Historical Nibbles, Jennifer!

by Jennifer Allen

In the break room at my first “real” job in Zanesville, Ohio, I unpacked my lunch and took out an oblong roll.

A colleague looked at it and asked what it was.

“A pepperoni roll.” I was surprised. I’d grown up on pepperoni rolls. I thought everybody knew about them.

So my colleague asked what exactly is a pepperoni roll.

As I explained, I realized for the first time that pepperoni rolls are a regional food, hardly known outside eastern Ohio and West Virginia.

The History of the Pepperoni Roll

In the early 1900’s, many immigrants, including Italians, flooded into West Virginia to work in the coal mines. According to A Culinary History of West Virginia, a baker named Joseph Argrio noticed that the miners often wrapped bread around meat for their meals in the mine. He baked pepperoni into the bread, making a handy, no mess sandwich with a long shelf life.

Mr. Argrio’s bakery was in Fairmont, West Virginia. My mother’s family lived near there and in neighboring Harrison County. I don’t know when my grandmother began baking pepperoni rolls, but my mom always has and now I do.

Pepperoni rolls are the most convenient lunch I know. They don’t require refrigeration. They last at least 5 days on the counter, and then I put them in the fridge only to preserve the bread. My oldest takes a couple with him on the band bus when he has an away football game. They’re perfect for a meal or snack on a hike.

When I created my fictional family for my cozy mystery series, Rae Riley Mysteries, I had to make the grandparents come from West Virginia. Not only would that give my characters a history common with my own, I could include pepperoni rolls whenever I needed to.

Recipe

1 loaf of frozen dough, such as Rhodes, for a 9×5 pan (If you use homemade bread, use the amount for one loaf pan.)

48 slices of pizza pepperoni or 12-18 slices of deli pepperoni or 12-18 slices of stick pepperoni

      (There are some people who prefer stick over slices. I always use small, sliced pizza pepperoni)

Thaw loaf.

Or

Make your preferred kind of bread. Let rise. Knead down. Then follow the steps below.

Preheat oven to 375 degrees. Grease or spray 1 cookie sheet.

Cut doubt into 8 roughly equal pieces.

Flatten one piece of dough until it is wide enough to lay 3 pizza pepperoni slices, overlapping.

Roll dough over pepperoni.

Lay 3 more slices.

Roll over dough and seal seams.

Place on cookie sheet. When 8 rolls are made, cover with light cloth and let raise for 2-3 hours.

Bake 10-13 minutes.

Eat when cooled to desired temperature.

Freeze leftovers if desired.

Some people add cheese and other ingredients but the original pepperoni roll was simply pepperoni baked into a roll.

BIO: JPC Allen started her writing career in second grade with an homage to Scooby Doo, and she’s been tracking down mysteries ever since. Her Christmas mystery “A Rose from the Ashes” was the first Rae Riley mystery and her latest Rae Riley novel, A Storm of Doubts released in March 2024. Online, she offers tips and prompts for every kind of writer. Follow her to her next mystery at FacebookBookBub, and Goodreads.

BLURB: Twenty-year-old Rae Riley’s desire to help people in trouble puts her at odds with her newly-found father, Mal. When she extends that help to her con man uncle and the ex-wife of a family friend, she and Mal clash even more. Then the ex-wife disappears. Rae works to discover what really happened as her uncle makes Rae doubt she’s calling the right Malinowski “Dad”.

BUY LINKS: Amazon and Goodreads

Fudge Brownies using Cocoa Powder

by Sandra Merville Hart

I decided to make brownies last week only to discover I didn’t any unsweetened chocolate in my pantry. There was an abundance of cocoa powder so I set about modifying my sister’s old recipe. It took a couple of batches before I settled on this recipe.

Ingredients

10 tablespoons of butter

¾ cup unsweetened cocoa powder

1 ¼ cups sugar

2 eggs

1 teaspoon vanilla

¾ cup all-purpose flour

½ cup chopped walnuts (optional)

Preheat oven to 350 degrees.

Simmer water in a large saucepan.

Place the butter in a metal or glass bowl. When the water is simmering, place the bowl over the top of the pan to melt the butter. Once the butter is melted, add the cocoa powder and sugar a little at a time, stirring with each addition.

Remove from heat. Set the bowl aside to cool for ten minutes.

Beat the eggs in a separate bowl and stir into the cooled mixture. Add the vanilla. Once those are all mixed together, stir in the flour, following with the walnuts, if desired. Mix well.

The chocolatey batter should be thick and creamy.

Prepare 8×8 baking pan with cooking spray. Pour chocolate batter into the prepared pan, spreading the mixture to the sides with a spoon.

Bake until a toothpick inserted in the center comes out clean, about 22-24 minutes. Allow brownies to cool and then cut into 16 squares.

This takes less than twenty minutes to prepare, not including baking time. It’s very easy to make brownies from scratch.

Using cocoa powder instead of unsweetened chocolate squares gave the brownies a richer, chocolaty flavor. Delicious and easy!

Enjoy!

Broccoli Casserole Recipe

by Sandra Merville Hart

A restaurant near my home recently added broccoli casserole to their listing of side dishes. It’s delicious! I’ve ordered it three or four times before deciding to create my own version. It’s been a few years since I’ve made one because my husband doesn’t like broccoli. I can’t believe how well this new recipe turned out! It’s so easy! The longest part of the preparation was chopping the fresh broccoli florets and steaming them. It requires about twenty minutes to prepare, not including baking.

Preheat oven to 350 degrees.

INGREDIENTS

6 cups chopped fresh broccoli florets (3 heads)

½ teaspoon salt

½ cup shredded cheddar cheese

2 tablespoons shredded mozzarella cheese

2-3 slices Colby or American cheese

2 tablespoons butter, melted

Ritz crackers, about 15

In a medium saucepan, heat about ½ cup of water (should be enough water so that the water level is about an inch) to simmering boil. Add fresh broccoli, cover, and reduce heat to low and cook until almost tender or about 7 minutes.

(If using frozen broccoli, reduce the cook time to 4-5 minutes.)

Remove broccoli from heat. Drain.

Prepare a medium-sized casserole dish with cooking spray. Add the broccoli to the dish. Next, layer the Colby or American cheese (I used Colby) on top of the broccoli. It won’t completely cover the vegetable—it adds to the melted goodness of the other cheeses.

Next, sprinkle on the mozzarella cheese. Then sprinkle on the cheddar cheese. (You may not need the whole ½ cup, depending on the dish you use.)

Crumble the Ritz crackers over the top. Then drizzle the melted butter on top.

Bake in a 350 oven for about 20 minutes or until the crackers on top are lightly browned.

Delicious! The blend of the three cheeses absolutely melts in my mouth. It gives the casserole a bit of the creaminess that other recipes add with creamy soups or mayonnaise mixtures.

Since my husband doesn’t eat this vegetable, this side dish is sometimes my main meal for lunch. I love it and hope you will too.   

Enjoy!

Christmas Dinner in the 1870s

by Sandra Merville Hart

Christmas dinner is a big meal at our house. We roast a turkey large enough to feed the family and provide leftovers for pot pies and sandwiches. There are plenty of side dishes with everyone’s holiday favorites. Dessert always includes at least pumpkin and chocolate pies. There are plenty of Christmas cookies too.

I thought this was a big meal until I read suggestions for Christmas dinners in an 1870s cookbook.

Here are the meats:

Clam soup, baked fish, Holland sauce;

Roast turkey with oyster dressing and celery or oyster sauce, roast duck with onion sauce, broiled quail, chicken pie

There were numerous side-dishes:

Baked potatoes in jackets, sweet potatoes, baked squash, stewed carrots, turnips, canned corn, southern cabbage, tomatoes, canned pease (peas);

Graham bread, rolls; plum jelly, crabapple jelly;

Salmon salad or herring salad, pickled cabbage, mangoes, French or Spanish pickles, Chili sauce, gooseberry catsup; and

Beets, sweet pickled grapes, and spiced nutmeg melon.

There were lots of dessert choices:

Christmas plum pudding with sauce, Charlotte Russe;

Pies—mince, peach, and coconut;

Cakes—citron, White Mountain, pound, Neapolitan, and French loaf;

Cookies—peppernuts, ladyfingers, centennial drops, almond or hickory nut macaroons;

Candy—coconut caramels, chocolate drops;

And even ice cream!—orange or pineapple

Beverage choices were coffee, tea, and Vienna chocolate.

If large families (grandparents, aunts, uncles, and cousins) prepared even a third of these dishes, they undoubtedly had one thing in common with us—leftovers!

Sources

Compiled from Original Recipes. Buckeye Cookery and Practical Housekeeping, Applewood Books, 1877.

 

 

 

Christmas Tree Veggie Tray

by Sandra Merville Hart

When planning a family Christmas party, I decided to create a Christmas Tree as my veggie tray. It’s a popular appetizer with my family and I thought this would be a fun way to serve it.

Chopping and preparing the vegetables was the time-consuming part of this.

Prepare small florets of broccoli and cauliflower.

Slice a cucumber.

Cut celery into 3” inch stalks.

Slice carrots into discs.

Use grape tomatoes or cherry tomatoes as they are.

Slice a red pepper into thin strips.

Hint: If you are taking this veggie tray to someone’s home, put it together there as it will not stay as arranged on the car ride over.

I covered a large cookie sheet with aluminum foil as my serving dish.

Arrange broccoli with a few florets of cauliflower in a tree shape.

Possible ornaments are cucumber slices, carrots, and cherry tomatoes. I have a few family members who don’t like cucumbers or tomatoes, so I only used carrots as my ornaments.

Arrange red pepper strips as garland on the tree.

Celery stalks become the tree trunk.

Vegetables that some folks won’t eat can be stacked at the bottom of the tree to emulate gifts.

Tomatoes became the star on the tree.

As folks begin eating it, replenish the veggies to retain the “tree” shape. 😊

This was a hit at our Christmas party. It’s a fun way to encourage children to eat their veggies at a party!

Mama Vada’s Coconut Pound Cake

I am thrilled that friend and fellow author, Debra DuPree Williams, is sharing one of her delicious Southern recipes from her debut novel. I couldn’t put it down! Welcome to Historical Nibbles, Debra!

By Debra DuPree Williams

One thing that will stand out to you as you read through my debut novel, Grave Consequences, is how often and how much the people within the pages eat. Set in rural south Alabama in 1968, the meals they share are typical of the meals I grew up eating.

From collard greens to fried corn to sliced red-ripe juicy tomatoes so well-known in that part of the great state of Alabama, the love of good home-cooked food is one thing we all share. Just writing this makes my mouth water.

I’m an unusual product of the south in that my Mama wasn’t a good cook. Well, she was, but she didn’t make everyday meals. She made party foods. Mama loved to entertain. Big time. I doubt there were two girls in all of Covington County, Alabama, who cut more crusts from little finger sandwiches than my sister and me. Every time we turned around our home was filled with ladies. Garden club ladies, Sunday School ladies, Altrusa Club ladies. And my teachers, both ladies and gentlemen.

Every Christmas, Mama made fruit cake. I hate fruitcake. Any kind. All that horrible candied fruit . . . and raisins. And she made Lane Cake. I hate Lane Cake. All those nasty little raisins.

But Mama made pound cake. The best, buttery-est, yummiest pound cakes. And she made a gorgeous bright-yellow cake called a Butter-Nut Cake. Y’all! It was sooo good. The frosting is to die for.

But, when my sister got married, she brought to our family her mother-in-law’s oh-so-delicious Coconut Pound Cake. In a scene from Grave Consequences, Charlotte fills plates with Granny’s (known as Miss Marge in the book) Tea Cakes and thick slices of Mama Vada’s Coconut Pound Cake. (She’s Aunt Vada in the book.)

This cake is so good, y’all, that my husband, who cannot stand the taste of coconut, loves it. Our sons, some of whom also hate coconut, love this cake. It’s that good.  Recipes for the Tea Cakes and the Coconut Pound Cake, along with other Southern delights, are in the back of Grave Consequences, but here’s a sneak peek just for you.

Here is the recipe.

Mama Vada’s Coconut Pound Cake

Do NOT preheat your oven!

1 cup butter, unsalted

2/3 cup Crisco (solid shortening)

3 cups sugar

5 eggs

3 cups flour (regular, all-purpose)

1 tsp. baking powder

1 cup whole milk

1 ½ tsp. coconut flavoring

1 cup flaked coconut

Cream together the sugar, butter, and shortening. Add the eggs, one at a time. Sift together the flour and baking powder. Add this to the creamed mixture, alternately with the milk and coconut flavoring. Stir in by hand, the flaked coconut. Bake in a tube pan at 325 degrees for 1 ½ hours. (I bake mine in a Bundt cake pan. Take out about a cup or so of the batter if you choose to use the Bundt pan, as this will be too much batter for that pan. Bake yourself a little cake as a treat for being so good to your family.)

PUT INTO A COLD OVEN! Don’t turn it on until after you put the cake inside.

Your home will fill with the aroma of this yummy cake. And it is gorgeous. The outside is flaky and crusty. The inside is moist and so good.

This recipe was given to our family by my sister’s mother-in-law, Vada Cross Foshee Grissett. I’ve made this so many times and it is always a hit.

No wonder Mama, Polly Graves, whipped one up for dessert at Rose Haven.

Back Cover Blurb

Sometimes finding the living is more difficult than searching for the dead. 

In 1968, twenty-six-year-old Charlotte Graves wrestles with more than just her decision to return to her hometown, Loblolly, Alabama—she is also fleeing a broken heart, colliding headlong into a second one, and about to stumble onto a deadly secret.

Now settled back in Loblolly, Charlotte is hired to oversee the Woodville County Historical Society, a job she was born for. But no sooner has she banged the gavel to bring order to the first meeting than she is accused of being incompetent to lead the group by her old nemesis, Boopsie Sweets. Later that night, she finds herself arrested by her old beau, the current deputy sheriff, Roan Steele, for killing Boopsie.

After being released on bail, Charlotte uses her skills as a genealogist to leap into the investigation. And when Charlotte goes digging up dirt, she unearths a long-kept family secret. Will it lead to Boopsie’s murderer … or to grave consequences for Charlotte and her family?

About Debra

Debra DuPree Williams is an award-winning author whose work has appeared in Yvonne Lehman’s Stupid Moments, Additional Christmas Moments, Selah Award finalist, Moments with Billy Graham, and Michelle Medlock Adams’s Love and Care for the One and Only You, expanded edition, in addition to other publications. When she isn’t busy writing, you will likely find Debbie chasing an elusive ancestor, either through online sources or in rural graveyards. Debbie is a classically-trained lyric coloratura soprano whose first love is Southern Gospel. She’s been married forever to the best man on earth, is the mother of four sons, mother-in-law of one extraordinary daughter-of-her-heart, and DD to the two most intelligent, talented, and beautiful young ladies ever. Debbie and her husband live in the majestic mountains of North Carolina.

Connect with Debra on her blog.

Amazon

Broccoli Salad Recipe

by Sandra Merville Hart

There’s a café near my daughter’s house that makes delicious broccoli salad. I decided to create my own version of this salad. It turned out pretty well and took about twenty minutes to prepare.

INGREDIENTS

Salad

5-6 cups small broccoli florets (3 heads)

½ cup shredded cheddar cheese

¼ cup bacon, cooked and crumbled

1 cup brown rice, cooked (optional)

Dressing

¾ cup mayonnaise

¼ cup olive oil

2 tablespoons white vinegar

2 tablespoons honey

¼ teaspoon salt

¼ teaspoon pepper

Stir the mayo and olive oil together until well blended. Then add vinegar, honey, salt, and pepper. Stir together until creamy. Set aside.

In a different bowl, combine the broccoli, cheese, and bacon. Pour in the dressing and stir until combined. Refrigerate for at least an hour before serving.

This was delicious! It tasted very similar to my favorite café’s version. The vinegar gives the creamy dressing a nice tangy flavor. I added a cup of cooked brown rice to the salad—it didn’t affect the flavor but made it a more filling, satisfying dish.

Something crunchy like ¼ cup of sunflowers or ½ cup of slivered almonds would be a nice addition.

Enjoy!

Try Some Amish Style Pie

Welcome to writer Julie Dearyan, who is here to share a pie recipe with us. Welcome to Historical Nibbles, Julie!

By Julie Dearyan
 
Pie is the quintessential, special occasion (or any occasion) dessert in rural Ohio. We love every kind of pie. Since we live in Amish country, we are the lucky recipients of Amish baking prowess.

At an Amish style banquet, a triangular shaped piece is parked at each plate topped with real (no skimping here) whipped cream. A variety of luscious fillings peek from beneath their cloudlike blankets. Peanut butter (always a winner), coconut (yum!), blueberry (more of a jelly filling than the ones my mom made growing up), raspberry, strawberry, blackberry, black raspberry, and more. The golden, flaky crust provides the perfect crunch.

Early on, some smart Ohioans showed us a rite of passage when entering an Amish restaurant or banquet. Check out the pieces of pies at each place first. Decide if you like that kind or quickly swap it out before the next diner comes. Neal and I are extremely grateful to those teachers. I always go for coconut or peanut butter. Down below, I share a recipe for Amish style peanut butter cream pie that I think you’ll enjoy. Your guests will love it too.

Amish Peanut Butter Pie
Adapted from https://www.thebakingchocolatess.com/amish-peanut-butter-cream-pie/
 
1 pie crust 9-inch, baked and cooled or make your own crust. Marty (the best cook I know) tells me there is no shame in buying a Pillsbury pie crust. Since she is the best cook I know, I agree with her.
Peanut Butter Crumbles
·       ½ cup powdered sugar
·       ¼ cup creamy peanut butter
Peanut Butter Filling
·       1 3.4 ounce box of instant Jell-O vanilla pudding mix 
·       1 ½ cups milk
·       ½ cup peanut butter
·       1 cup whipped cream 
Whipped Topping On Top of Pie
·       2 cups whipped cream Using mixer, whip together on medium-high 1 cup of whipping cream and 3 tablespoons of powdered sugar to get whipped cream texture. 1 cup of whipping cream makes 2 cups when whipped.
Using an electric mixer, in a medium bowl, add powdered sugar and peanut butter. Mix on medium speed until small peanut butter crumbles start to come together. If mixture is too powdery, simply add a few drops of water to the and larger nuggets will form. Add half the peanut butter nuggets to the bottom of the pie shell.
Using a mixer, mix together the dry vanilla instant pudding mix, milk and peanut butter together for 2 minutes. Add in the whipped cream (make sure it’s already whipped) and mix in lightly. Pour pudding into pie crust on top of the peanut butter crumbles.
Top with whipped cream. Add the remaining peanut butter crumbles to the top of the whipped cream. Let the pie cool in the refrigerator for at least 1-2 hours to set up before cutting.